The Sentence is Death by Anthony Horowitz

September 10, 2019

The Sentence is Death by Anthony Horowitz

Screenwriter Anthony Horowitz is once again approached by P. I. Daniel Hawthorne (both last seen in The Word is Murder) with a new case.  A wealthy and well-known divorce lawyer has been murdered by being hit over the head with an expensive bottle of bottle, and then stabbed with the bottle shards.  The number 182 is painted on the wall of the room where he was killed.  There are numerous suspects, all with secrets and good reasons to murder the lawyer, including the lawyer's husband, a couple of clients, and an old school friend.  Hawthorne wants writer Horowitz (who appears as a character in his own mystery) to once again be Watson to Hawthorne's Sherlock Holmes.

I loved Magpie Murders and was so disappointed that there weren’t really any Atticus Pund mysteries - Atticus Pund was a wonderful character.  While the Hawthorne mysteries are clever, they just aren't as good because P. I. Hawthorne is abrasive, racist, homophobic, and unlikeable.  Horowitz tries to make him sound mysterious but he’s not – he’s a secretive anti-social loner who treats other people with disdain.  There are a number of minor characters and side plots that really didn't add much to the mystery (the characters at the book club, Horowitz's agent, Lenny the informant, a couple of really brutal constables, etc.).  By the end of the book, even Horowitz is trying to break off his relationship with Hawthorne.

While this was an interesting mystery with a couple of good twists, I listened to the audio version and I disliked the reader – all of the characters except Hawthorne sound shrill and whiny.  I think I’ll stick to the print version for any future titles in the series.