When All Is Said by Anne Griffin

February 19, 2020

When All Is Said by Anne Griffin

Maurice Hannigan, an 84 years old widower, has sold his huge property holdings, packed up all his worldly goods, and found a new home for his dog Gearshift.  He hasn’t told anyone about his plans except his solicitor, telling the solicitor he is going to a senior citizen home.  He sits in a hotel bar, reminiscing about the five people who have meant the most to him and drinks a toast to each one, addressing his memories to his absent son. 

I usually love books set in Ireland, but this wasn’t as enjoyable as I expected it to be.  Maurice is a curmudgeon, but he’s not as appealing a protagonist as Ove in Fredrik Backman’s A Man Called Ove (which I’m kind of glad about since I loved Backman’s book).  Much of Maurice’s story centers around a gold coin that he stole as a boy.  He is angry, stubborn, and depressed his whole life, seeking revenge on the local family he believes to be responsible for all of his misery.  Although he claims to adore his wife, he was a domineering husband who never took her to a restaurant that she really wanted to eat at, or let her order a cup of tea in a restaurant (in Maurice’s opinion, they had perfectly good tea at home).  He was a wealthy man but never gave her any gifts except her wedding ring – instead, he would just hand her cash on her birthday or Christmas.  Ultimately, Maurice never tells those five people how important they were to him.

Great writing, depressing story. 

If you want a really good story about a curmudgeon, read Backman’s A Man Called Ove.  If you want a really good story set in Ireland, read John Boyne’s The Heart’s Invisible Furies instead.