August 30, 2020
Since they were children, Alina Dziak knew she was going to marry Tomascz Slaski because they were perfect for each other. In 1938, when he turns 18, Tomascz leaves their small town to travel to Krakow to attend the university so that he can become a doctor like his father. He and Alina become engaged before he leaves, and Tomascz vows he will always return to Alina. But World War II is looming and the Nazis interrupt their plans when they invade Poland. Seventy years later, Alina suffers a stroke and what may be her final wish is for her granddaughter Alice to go to Poland to find out what happened to Alina's family.
This is another one of those historical novels that has a historical narrative that alternates with a modern narrative. It's more like a historical fiction/women's fiction hybrid, since the modern story is pure women's fiction. This seems to be Kelly Rimmer's style, based on the other books she has written. It took me a while to get into this one, mostly because I didn't like Alice, the main character in the modern storyline. She was a bully and a know-it-all, even though she was remarkably stupid at times. Her husband was almost perfect, like a guy out of a fantasy romance novel. However, Alina and Tomascz's story redeemed the novel, and although I still disliked Alice, I stayed with the book because I wanted to find out about their story.
Readers who enjoyed The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah, Lilac Girls by Martha Hall Kelly, or All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr should enjoy this one, although I thought those were all better books. Women who like women's fiction will read it for the modern narrative.